The Government wants all of us show a passport or driving license to use social media.
This is a digital ID scheme by the backdoor.
The Government is demanding ID checks to carry out a social media ban for under-16s. But there’s no such thing as a state-enforced social media ban ‘for children’ – only digital identity checks for all of us.
This fight is too important to lose. If we do nothing, large parts of the internet will be behind the Government's Great British Firewall within a few months.
The British people have always rejected mandatory ID schemes, and now we must once again come together and say no to a “papers, please” society. Because, if this becomes a reality, future generations will not remember it as a child safety policy. It will be remembered as the moment Britain introduced digital gatekeepers.
EMAIL YOUR MP
Tell your MP you don't want digital ID by the backdoor. Make sure you personalise your email with your name, postcode, and your own reasoned arguments and feelings introducing digital checks for the internet.
Step 1: Select your MP from the list below:
If you're not sure who your MP is, you can find out here.
Jack AbbottLabourIpswich
Ms Diane AbbottLabourHackney North and Stoke Newington
Debbie AbrahamsLabourOldham East and Saddleworth
Shockat AdamIndependentLeicester South
Dr Zubir AhmedLabourGlasgow South West
Luke AkehurstLabourNorth Durham
Bayo AlabaLabourSouthend East and Rochford
Daniel AldridgeLabourWeston-super-Mare
Heidi AlexanderLabourSwindon South
Mr Douglas AlexanderLabourLothian East
Sadik Al-HassanLabourNorth Somerset
Rushanara AliLabourBethnal Green and Stepney
Tahir AliLabourBirmingham Hall Green and Moseley
Dr Rosena Allin-KhanLabourTooting
Jim AllisterTraditional Unionist VoiceNorth Antrim
Sarah PochinReform UKRuncorn and Helsby
Mr Gideon AmosLiberal DemocratTaunton and Wellington
Bridget PhillipsonLabourHoughton and Sunderland South
Chris PhilpConservativeCroydon South
Al PinkertonLiberal DemocratSurrey Heath
David Pinto-DuschinskyLabourHendon
Lee PitcherLabourDoncaster East and the Isle of Axholme
Jo PlattLabourLeigh and Atherton
Luke PollardLabourPlymouth Sutton and Devonport
Joe PowellLabourKensington and Bayswater
Lucy PowellLabourManchester Central
Gregor PoyntonLabourLivingston
Peter PrinsleyLabourBury St Edmunds and Stowmarket
Mark PritchardConservativeThe Wrekin
Richard QuigleyLabourIsle of Wight West
Yasmin QureshiLabourBolton South and Walkden
Steve RaceLabourExeter
Shivani RajaConservativeLeicester East
Adrian RamsayGreen PartyWaveney Valley
Mr Connor RandLabourAltrincham and Sale West
Andrew RangerLabourWrexham
Jack RankinConservativeWindsor
Angela RaynerLabourAshton-under-Lyne
Mike ReaderLabourNorthampton South
David ReedConservativeExmouth and Exeter East
Steve ReedLabourStreatham and Croydon North
Ellie ReevesLabourLewisham West and East Dulwich
Rachel ReevesLabourLeeds West and Pudsey
Joani ReidLabourEast Kilbride and Strathaven
Emma ReynoldsLabourWycombe
Jonathan ReynoldsLabourStalybridge and Hyde
Mr Joshua ReynoldsLiberal DemocratMaidenhead
Martin RhodesLabourGlasgow North
Bell Ribeiro-AddyLabourClapham and Brixton Hill
Jake RichardsLabourRother Valley
Jenny Riddell-CarpenterLabourSuffolk Coastal
Lucy RigbyLabourNorthampton North
Ms Marie RimmerLabourSt Helens South and Whiston
Dave RobertsonLabourLichfield
Joe RobertsonConservativeIsle of Wight East
Gavin RobinsonDemocratic Unionist PartyBelfast East
Tim RocaLabourMacclesfield
Matt RoddaLabourReading Central
Ian RoomeLiberal DemocratNorth Devon
Andrew RosindellConservativeRomford
Sam RushworthLabourBishop Auckland
Mrs Sarah RussellLabourCongleton
Tom RutlandLabourEast Worthing and Shoreham
Oliver RyanLabourBurnley
Anna SabineLiberal DemocratFrome and East Somerset
Sarah SackmanLabourFinchley and Golders Green
Jeevun SandherLabourLoughborough
Dr Roz SavageLiberal DemocratSouth Cotswolds
Liz Saville RobertsPlaid CymruDwyfor Meirionnydd
Michelle ScroghamLabourBarrow and Furness
Mr Mark SewardsLabourLeeds South West and Morley
Naz ShahLabourBradford West
Baggy ShankerLabourDerby South
Michael ShanksLabourRutherglen
Jim ShannonDemocratic Unionist PartyStrangford
Dr Neil Shastri-HurstConservativeSolihull West and Shirley
Sir Alec ShelbrookeConservativeWetherby and Easingwold
Tulip SiddiqLabourHampstead and Highgate
David SimmondsConservativeRuislip, Northwood and Pinner
Andy BurnhamLabourMakerfield
Vikki SladeLiberal DemocratMid Dorset and North Poole
Andy SlaughterLabourHammersmith and Chiswick
John SlingerLabourRugby
Lisa SmartLiberal DemocratHazel Grove
Cat SmithLabourLancaster and Wyre
David SmithLabourNorth Northumberland
Greg SmithConservativeMid Buckinghamshire
Jeff SmithLabourManchester Withington
Nick SmithLabourBlaenau Gwent and Rhymney
Rebecca SmithConservativeSouth West Devon
Sarah SmithLabourHyndburn
Sir Julian SmithConservativeSkipton and Ripon
Karin SmythLabourBristol South
Gareth SnellLabourStoke-on-Trent Central
Mr Andrew SnowdenConservativeFylde
Alex SobelLabourLeeds Central and Headingley
Ian SollomLiberal DemocratSt Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire
Dr Ben SpencerConservativeRunnymede and Weybridge
Patrick SpencerConservativeCentral Suffolk and North Ipswich
Greg StaffordConservativeFarnham and Bordon
Euan StainbankLabourFalkirk
Sagal Abdi-WaliLabourHolborn and St Pancras
Blake StephensonConservativeMid Bedfordshire
Jo StevensLabourCardiff East
Kenneth StevensonLabourAirdrie and Shotts
Elaine StewartLabourAyr, Carrick and Cumnock
Jamie StoneLiberal DemocratCaithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
Will StoneLabourSwindon North
Alistair StrathernLabourHitchin
Wes StreetingLabourIlford North
Alan StricklandLabourNewton Aycliffe and Spennymoor
Mel StrideConservativeCentral Devon
Graham StringerLabourBlackley and Middleton South
Graham StuartConservativeBeverley and Holderness
Dr Lauren SullivanLabourGravesham
Kirsteen SullivanLabourBathgate and Linlithgow
Zarah SultanaLabourCoventry South
Rishi SunakConservativeRichmond and Northallerton
Peter SwallowLabourBracknell
Robin SwannUlster Unionist PartySouth Antrim
Sir Desmond SwayneConservativeNew Forest West
Mark TamiLabourAlyn and Deeside
Mike TappLabourDover and Deal
Alison TaylorLabourPaisley and Renfrewshire North
David TaylorLabourHemel Hempstead
Luke TaylorLiberal DemocratSutton and Cheam
Rachel TaylorLabourNorth Warwickshire and Bedworth
Bradley ThomasConservativeBromsgrove
Cameron ThomasLiberal DemocratTewkesbury
Fred ThomasLabourPlymouth Moor View
Gareth ThomasLabourHarrow West
Nick Thomas-SymondsLabourTorfaen
Adam ThompsonLabourErewash
Emily ThornberryLabourIslington South and Finsbury
Richard TiceReform UKBoston and Skegness
Marie TidballLabourPenistone and Stocksbridge
Sir Stephen TimmsLabourEast Ham
Nick TimothyConservativeWest Suffolk
Jessica ToaleLabourBournemouth West
Dan TomlinsonLabourChipping Barnet
Jon TrickettLabourNormanton and Hemsworth
Laura TrottConservativeSevenoaks
Henry TufnellLabourMid and South Pembrokeshire
Tom TugendhatConservativeTonbridge
Anna TurleyLabourRedcar
Matt TurmaineLabourWatford
Karl TurnerLabourKingston upon Hull East
Laurence TurnerLabourBirmingham Northfield
Derek TwiggLabourWidnes and Halewood
Liz TwistLabourBlaydon and Consett
Harpreet UppalLabourHuddersfield
Freddie Van MierloLiberal DemocratHenley and Thame
Tony VaughanLabourFolkestone and Hythe
Valerie VazLabourWalsall and Bloxwich
Martin VickersConservativeBrigg and Immingham
Matt VickersConservativeStockton West
Chris VinceLabourHarlow
Caroline VoadenLiberal DemocratSouth Devon
Christian WakefordLabourBury South
Imogen WalkerLabourHamilton and Clyde Valley
Chris WardLabourBrighton Kemptown and Peacehaven
Melanie WardLabourCowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy
Paul WaughLabourRochdale
Chris WebbLabourBlackpool South
Michelle WelshLabourSherwood Forest
Catherine WestLabourHornsey and Friern Barnet
Andrew WesternLabourStretford and Urmston
Matt WesternLabourWarwick and Leamington
Helen WhatelyConservativeFaversham and Mid Kent
Michael WheelerLabourWorsley and Eccles
John WhitbyLabourDerbyshire Dales
Jo WhiteLabourBassetlaw
Katie WhiteLabourLeeds North West
Sir John WhittingdaleConservativeMaldon
Nadia WhittomeLabourNottingham East
James WildConservativeNorth West Norfolk
Max WilkinsonLiberal DemocratCheltenham
David WilliamsLabourStoke-on-Trent North
Sir Gavin WilliamsonConservativeStone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge
Munira WilsonLiberal DemocratTwickenham
Sammy WilsonDemocratic Unionist PartyEast Antrim
Pete WishartScottish National PartyPerth and Kinross-shire
Steve WitherdenLabourMontgomeryshire and Glynd?r
Mike WoodConservativeKingswinford and South Staffordshire
Sean WoodcockLabourBanbury
Sir Jeremy WrightConservativeKenilworth and Southam
Rosie WrightingLabourKettering
Martin WrigleyLiberal DemocratNewton Abbot
Yuan YangLabourEarley and Woodley
Mohammad YasinLabourBedford
Steve YemmLabourMansfield
Claire YoungLiberal DemocratThornbury and Yate
Daniel ZeichnerLabourCambridge
Please select an MP from the list above. You have selected: mp name goes here. Click here to choose again.
6 KEY ARGUMENTS AGAINST PASSPORTS FOR THE INTERNET
1. This will not make children safer online
Everyone wants children to be safe online – but the Government’s social media ban isn’t what it says on the tin.
In Australia, the government’s social media ban has resulted in over 80% of children continuing to use social media platforms. Other children will continue to socialise online but in less regulated corners of the internet, making them less safe. Bans also cause children to hide their social media use from parents, giving them no one to turn to if things go wrong.
The social media ban is opposed by over 40 expert child safety groups including the Molly Rose Foundation and NSPCC, as well as many human rights and digital rights groups.
Further, government social media bans disincentivise social media companies to implement child safety measures, creating new child safety risks.
Children's online safety requires better parental controls and thoughtful tech regulation. Displacing parental responsibilities onto the Government gives way to checkpoints and controls not just for children but for the British public as a whole – and we may find that we’re handing the next generation a new fight for liberty.
2. Digital ID by the backdoor
It is impossible to restrict social media use just ‘for children’.
The technological reality is this: all Britons will be forced to undergo ID checks to use social media. Currently, the Government plans to require government-issued IDs: passports or driving licenses.
This is not a policy without resistance. Recent polling shows that support for a social media ban drops substantially when it is enforced through digital ID checks. People are realising what we have argued consistently: a social media ban is a Trojan horse for digital ID.
3. HONEYPOT FOR HACKERS
A system where millions of us have to share sensitive identity documents with foreign tech companies would be a prime target for hackers, cyber-criminals and hostile states - let alone risking misuse by the companies themselves.
Bad actors may also create fraudulent ID checking systems. At a time when the UK is experiencing greater cybersecurity threats than ever, the risk of such a system is particularly serious.
Companies that already use ID verification, such as Discord, lost around 70,000 users’ photos each last year. The women caught up in the scandal had their photos posted to the notorious site 4chan. For 16 and 17-year-olds this policy is even riskier. It will, in practice, see the ID documents of millions of children uploaded to the internet.
The Government should encourage people – adults and children alike – to minimise ID sharing online, rather than turning our most widely used online platforms into ID checkpoints.
4. The end of online anonymity
There is no anonymous way to process a passport or driver’s licence online. This means that under this proposal, every social media account would be tied to an ID document, spelling the end of online anonymity.
There are many legitimate reasons why law-abiding citizens want to hide their identity online. Vulnerable communities in particular, such as victims of sexual or domestic abuse, members of the LGBTQ community, those belonging to (or leaving) religious groups, as well as whistleblowers, journalists and campaigners all rely on online anonymity for their safety and freedom of expression.
5. Discriminatory and undemocratic
According to the Electoral Commission, four million adults do not have a passport or driving license. The proportion of people without such documents is even higher among lower income or marginalised communities. 16 and 17 year olds cannot hold a credit card, and many will not hold a driving licence either.
Requiring ID to access social media would prevent millions of people from exercising their freedom of speech in the spaces where, in practice, most of our civic debate takes place. This has serious implications for our democracy, and constitutes a total reshaping of modern civil liberty that will affect us all.
6. Other countries are fighting back
Several governments across the world are trying to implement social media bans, but are facing resistance at every turn. France’s top court rejected a social media ban for under-15s, citing that it was incompatible with freedom of expression and privacy.
The moment Australia’s social media ban was implemented, it faced a legal challenge launched by two teenagers standing up for their human rights. Just this month, India’s Supreme Court blocked a social media ban on the grounds that internet access is a universal human right.
Big Brother Watch is a proud member of Stop Killing the Internet, a huge international coalition of digital rights activists and organisations opposing privacy-infringing policies like digital ID and age verification for the internet.
THE GREAT BRITISH FIREWALL
The Government’s raft of online “safety” policies stand to make the UK’s internet one of the most controlled in the democratic world.
This includes forcing tech companies to introduce ‘device-level controls’. Tech giant Apple recently introduced mandatory age and identity checks at the operating system level.
In simple terms, your iPhone now requires you to prove your age before you can freely browse the web or use certain apps. Our director Silkie Carlo wrote to Apple demanding they drop this ID demand and restore internet freedom to millions of people in the UK.
